Lippy

Guide · Law firms

Choosing a law firm
answering service.

What a law firm needs from an answering service: intake by practice area, conflict screening, confidentiality under the ABA Model Rules, typical costs, and a worked example of a Saturday-night injury call.

Law firm answering service: intake, ethics, and costs

Updated November 20, 2026

This guide is written by Lippy, a managed AI receptionist that answers, books, and follows up on calls for businesses. Most of it applies whichever option you choose. How Lippy handles this is near the end.

Three kinds of calls, three different jobs

A law firm’s phone gets calls that look similar but need opposite handling. An answering service has to tell them apart within the first minute:

CallerWhat they needWhat the service should do
Potential new clientTo know whether the firm will take the caseRun the intake script for the matter type, screen for conflicts, book a consultation or route to an intake attorney
Existing clientAn update, a document, a personTake a detailed message for the responsible attorney or paralegal; never discuss the matter
Court, opposing counsel, vendorsTo reach a specific personTake the message or transfer per firm rules; don’t confirm who the firm represents

For new-client calls, speed matters. Someone hurt in a crash, arrested, or served with papers often calls several firms in a row, and the first one that answers and books a consultation usually gets the meeting.

Options for law firms

  • In-house receptionist or intake team. Best judgment, but coverage ends at 5 or 6 p.m., and many injury and criminal-defense calls come in at night and on weekends.
  • A general answering service. Takes messages. Operators usually aren’t trained on legal intake, so every message needs a full callback.
  • A legal intake service. Operators trained to run intake scripts by practice area; many work around the clock. Priced above general message taking.
  • An AI intake service. Answers every call immediately, runs scripted intake by matter type, collects conflict information, and books consultations or hands off to a person.

What legal call answering costs

Typical US costs, November 2026
OptionTypical cost
Receptionist on payrollMedian $17.90 an hour, about $37,230 a year (BLS, May 2024), before taxes and benefits
Live answering serviceAbout $159–$395 a month for 100 minutes; per-call plans about $8.50–$11.50 a call
Legal intake serviceAbove general answering rates, because intake calls run longer and use custom scripts; quoted per firm
AI intakeSelf-serve AI plans from about $14–$150 a month; managed services cost more and include script building and testing

Ranges come from published pricing for US providers we reviewed in November 2026. Plans change often, so check current terms before you compare.

Intake calls are long. A personal injury intake that covers the accident, injuries, treatment, insurance, and other parties can take 10 minutes. Forty intakes a month at 10 minutes is 400 minutes before any routine calls. Price on minutes, not calls.

Your confidentiality duties still apply

Outsourcing the phones doesn’t outsource the firm’s ethical obligations. The ABA Model Rules and opinions most firms look to:

  • Model Rule 5.3. When a firm uses an outside service, comment 3 says lawyers must make reasonable efforts to ensure the service works in a way compatible with their professional obligations, considering the service’s experience, the nature of the work, and the confidentiality arrangements.
  • Formal Opinion 08-451 on outsourcing. Before outside providers receive confidential client information, the firm should consider whether client consent is needed, and written confidentiality agreements are strongly advisable. It also suggests confirming the provider isn’t working for adverse parties.
  • Prospective clients. Information from someone consulting the firm about a possible matter is generally protected even if the firm never takes the case, so intake data needs the same care as client data.

In practice, that means a signed confidentiality agreement, knowing where recordings and transcripts are stored and who can access them, and a script that gives legal information but never legal advice. Your state bar may have its own rules and opinions; check them. This guide isn’t legal advice.

What a good intake script covers

  1. Matter type first, so the right script runs. Personal injury, family, criminal, employment, and estate intake ask different questions.
  2. Disqualifiers early: wrong practice area, outside your jurisdiction, past a deadline the firm flags. Decline politely and, if you choose, refer out.
  3. Names of every other party, for a conflict check before anything substantive is discussed. Potential conflicts go to a person to decide.
  4. Key facts for the matter type, such as accident date, injuries and treatment, or charge and court date.
  5. Contact details, the best time to call back, and whether it is safe to leave a message. This matters in family law.
  6. The next step: a booked consultation, a callback from an intake attorney, or a polite decline.

Example: a Saturday-night injury call

A six-attorney personal injury firm forwards its line to an intake service after 6 p.m. and on weekends. At 10:15 p.m. on a Saturday, a caller says she was rear-ended on the highway that afternoon and her neck hurts.

  1. The service runs the motor-vehicle intake script: date and location, whether police came, injuries, treatment so far, the other driver’s name and insurer, and whether she has spoken to another attorney.
  2. The other driver’s name and the insurer go into the conflict check. No match.
  3. She asks, “Do I have a case?” The service says an attorney will review the details with her and that it can’t give legal advice.
  4. The case meets the firm’s criteria, so the service books a Monday 9 a.m. consultation and sends a confirmation text.
  5. The intake attorney gets a summary that night, flagged as a new auto-accident matter with treatment ongoing.

Ten minutes later, an existing client calls asking about a settlement check. The service takes a message for the paralegal on the file and doesn’t discuss the case.

How Lippy handles law firm calls

Lippy answers the firm’s line 24/7 and runs your intake scripts by matter type. It gives legal information, never legal advice.

  • Collects the caller’s name and adverse or related parties for a conflict check. Potential hits go to a person; clear results can book a consultation.
  • Takes detailed messages from existing clients for the responsible attorney or paralegal.
  • Supports AI disclosure, consent capture, and opt-out handling, with settings per firm.
  • Our team builds and tests the scripts with you before any live call, and updates them as your criteria change.

FAQ

Common questions

Can a law firm ethically use an answering service?+

Yes, with reasonable supervision. ABA Model Rule 5.3 asks lawyers to make reasonable efforts to ensure outside services act consistently with their obligations, and Formal Opinion 08-451 recommends written confidentiality agreements. Check your state bar’s guidance too.

Will the answering service give legal advice?+

It shouldn’t. A well-written script lets the service explain what happens next and what information the firm needs, and tells callers that an attorney will review their situation.

How do answering services handle conflict checks?+

They collect the names of the caller and other parties early in the call. Some can check those names against the firm’s records; potential conflicts should always go to a person to decide before anything substantive is discussed.

How much does a law firm answering service cost?+

General live answering plans we reviewed in November 2026 ran about $159–$395 a month for 100 minutes. Legal intake calls are long, so estimate minutes from your intake volume, and expect intake-trained services to cost more than message taking.

Keep reading

All guides →
Marcia RibeiroSanta Barbara Corporate Services
“I have been using Lippy AI for my notary business for about two months and I LOVE IT! The portal is amazing and the AI secretary says exactly what I thought her to say. I have had great feedback from clients and love knowing that I don't have to pick up every call. I also appreciate that they can filter spam calls.”
Scott NelsonFBC Roofing
“Great company to partner with! I run a roofing business and they have helped in so many different ways. They are always available to make tweaks or changes on the spot. Heavily recommended company!”

Read all reviews ↓

Hear it run
your intake.

Bring an intake script for your busiest practice area. We’ll show you how Lippy screens, books, and hands off.

Get started→